De 45 liedjes waaruit het album bestaat, zijn de volgende:
Hier is een korte lijst van de liedjes gecomponeerd door Original Broadway Cast Of Hamilton die tijdens het concert zouden kunnen worden afgespeelden het referentiealbum:
- Helpless
- We Know
- Meet Me Inside
- Aaron Burr, Sir
- History Has Its Eyes on You
- Blow Us All Away
- Yorktown
- Stay Alive
- What'd I Miss
- Farmer Refuted
- Right Hand Man
- Guns and Ships
- Take a Break
- The Election of 1800
- Satisfied
- Non-Stop
- The Adams Administration
- Say No to This
- Wait for It
- The Reynolds Pamphlet
- A Winter's Ball
- Schuyler Defeated
- Cabinet Battle #1
- Hurricane
- Your Obedient Servant
- The Schuyler Sisters
- My Shot
- Washington on Your Side
- It's Quiet Uptown
- That Would Be Enough
- Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story
- Cabinet Battle #2
- I Know Him
- The Room Where It Happens
- The Story of Tonight
- Best of Wives and Best of Women
- Dear Theodosia
- Burn
- Ten Duel Commandments
- Alexander Hamilton
- You'll Be Back
- The World Was Wide Enough
- Tomorrow There'll Be More of Us
- What Comes Next?
- One Last Time